WWE Survivor Series 2015 Retro Review: Reigns' First Title, Sheamus' Cash-In and Every Match Rated

WWE Survivor Series 2015 took place on Sunday, November 22, 2015, at the Philips Arena in Atlanta, Georgia. It was built around a tournament for the vacant WWE World Heavyweight Championship and The Undertaker's 25th anniversary, 25 years after his debut at Survivor Series 1990.
Looking back, it is remembered for one thing: Roman Reigns winning the world title for the first time and losing it minutes later to Sheamus. The two tournament semifinals are good, Undertaker's night is a nice piece of nostalgia, and the rest is thin. It is a show that shows exactly where WWE was in late 2015.
The build
- The tournament: Roman Reigns had earned a title shot against Seth Rollins, but Rollins suffered serious knee injuries at a live event in Dublin on November 4, and the title was vacated. A tournament began on Raw, with the semifinals and final at Survivor Series. Triple H offered Reigns a straight path to the final if he joined The Authority. Reigns refused.
- The semifinals: Reigns vs. United States Champion Alberto Del Rio, and Dean Ambrose vs. Intercontinental Champion Kevin Owens.
- The Undertaker and Kane vs. The Wyatt Family: The Wyatts carried The Undertaker out of the arena after Hell in a Cell in October, then did the same to Kane. The Brothers of Destruction came back on November 9 and accepted Bray Wyatt's challenge.
- The Divas Championship: Paige won a fatal four-way against Becky Lynch, Brie Bella and Sasha Banks to earn a shot at Charlotte.
- Security: the FBI looked into an alleged online threat against an Atlanta venue the day before the show, and said there was no specific or credible information of an attack. WWE said the show would go ahead, and it did without incident.
Match by match
Kickoff: The Dudley Boyz, Goldust, Neville and Titus O'Neil vs. The Miz, Bo Dallas, Stardust, Konnor and Viktor
A traditional elimination match on the pre-show, put together from whoever was free. Goldust pinned Viktor in 30 seconds, Bubba Ray pinned Konnor, and The Miz took out Neville with help from Dallas before Goldust rolled up Miz. O'Neil eliminated Dallas, and the Dudleys put Stardust through a 3-D to finish it with four survivors in 18:10.
What worked: it was a reminder that a Survivor Series match can be fun with any ten wrestlers, and the crowd enjoyed the Dudleys.
What didn't: there was no story at all, and Neville, one of the best wrestlers on the roster, was gone halfway through.
Our rating: ★★½
Tournament semifinal: Roman Reigns vs. Alberto Del Rio
The show opened with Reigns against the United States Champion, with Zeb Colter in Del Rio's corner. It was a good, hard-hitting match, with Del Rio in control for long stretches and Reigns fighting from underneath. The ending was quick: Del Rio leapt off the top rope, Reigns moved, and caught him with a spear for the win at 14:05.
Del Rio had only been back in WWE for a month and was not a real threat to win, but he played his part well.
What worked: a solid opener with a clear story and a clean finish. Reigns looked strong without making it too easy.
What didn't: the result was never in doubt, which took a lot of the drama out of a match that needed to feel like a real tournament fight.
Our rating: ★★★¼
Tournament semifinal: Dean Ambrose vs. Kevin Owens
The best match of the night. Owens was the Intercontinental Champion and in the middle of his first great main roster run, and Ambrose was the most popular wrestler in the tournament. They had real chemistry, with Owens' power moves and Ambrose's wild, unpredictable style working well together.
The finish was very good. Owens went for the Pop-up Powerbomb, Ambrose turned it into a hurricanrana and hit Dirty Deeds for the win at 11:20. The crowd in Atlanta was firmly behind Ambrose, and the win set up two former Shield brothers in the final.
What worked: two of the best wrestlers in the company, a great crowd reaction and the best finishing sequence on the show.
What didn't: at just over 11 minutes, it was too short to become the classic it could have been. Owens deserved more time.
Our rating: ★★★½
The New Day, Sheamus and King Barrett vs. The Usos, The Lucha Dragons and Ryback
A traditional elimination match that was only put together in the last few days. Sin Cara pinned Barrett with a springboard senton, Xavier Woods pinned Jimmy Uso, and Sheamus answered with a Brogue Kick on Sin Cara. Jey Uso then pinned Big E with the Samoan Splash, and Kofi Kingston and Woods simply walked out with their partner, which eliminated them both.
That left Sheamus alone against three. He took a superkick from Jey, a hurricanrana from Kalisto and the Shell Shock from Ryback, who pinned him at 17:33. Ryback, Kalisto and Jey survived.
What worked: The New Day walking out was a funny bit that fit their characters perfectly, and the match moved quickly.
What didn't: Sheamus was booked as the fool of the match, abandoned by his team and pinned easily. On a night when he would leave as world champion, that was an odd choice, and it made his win at the end harder to take seriously.
Our rating: ★★★
Divas Championship: Charlotte (c) vs. Paige
Charlotte had won the title at Night of Champions in September, and Paige had turned on her after the so-called Divas Revolution group fell apart. The match had some good moments. The best came when Charlotte hit Natural Selection, Paige rolled out, climbed the barricade to taunt her, and Charlotte followed her up and speared her off it.
Charlotte won at 14:18 with the Figure Eight Leglock, holding the bottom rope with her arm under it to give herself more leverage.
What worked: the barricade spear was a big moment, and the finish showed Charlotte was willing to bend the rules, a sign of where her character was heading.
What didn't: for a supposed grudge match it never got much of a reaction, and the crowd did not seem sure who to cheer. Two of the best women on the roster deserved a better build.
Our rating: ★★½
Tyler Breeze vs. Dolph Ziggler
Breeze had debuted on the main roster a month earlier by attacking Ziggler, and this was their first match on a big show. It was short and fine. Ziggler, dressed in a tribute to Shawn Michaels, did most of the work, and Breeze won at 6:41 with the Unprettier, Christian's old finishing move.
What worked: Breeze got a clean win over an established name, which was the point.
What didn't: it was over too quickly to matter, and Ziggler copying Michaels' look made him feel like a tribute act. Neither man got anything lasting from it.
Our rating: ★★
The Undertaker and Kane vs. Bray Wyatt and Luke Harper
The Undertaker's 25th anniversary match, and the show's emotional high point. His entrance was huge, and the crowd, which had been quiet for most of the night, came alive. Before the match, The Brothers of Destruction chokeslammed Erick Rowan, and later they put Braun Strowman through the announce table with a double chokeslam.
The match itself was simple. Wyatt did his spider walk to taunt them, and both brothers sat up at the same time, which got a big pop. They hit double chokeslams on Wyatt and Harper, and The Undertaker pinned Harper with a Tombstone at 10:18.
What worked: as a celebration, it worked. The entrance and the sit-up are the moments people remember, and the crowd loved every second of it.
What didn't: The Wyatts, who had carried both brothers out of arenas a month earlier, were made to look like henchmen and lost without much of a fight. It did nothing for Wyatt, who badly needed a win.
Our rating: ★★½
Tournament final: Roman Reigns vs. Dean Ambrose
Two former Shield brothers for the vacant WWE World Heavyweight Championship. They had a competitive but short match. Reigns caught Ambrose in the air with a Superman Punch for a near fall and hit a spear for another. Ambrose sent Reigns into the ring post and nearly stole it with a roll-up, then hit Dirty Deeds for a close two count. Reigns hit a second spear and won at 9:02, his first world championship.
The crowd was split, and many fans clearly wanted Ambrose. At nine minutes, the final of a tournament that had taken three weeks felt rushed.
What worked: the near falls in the closing minutes were good, and the respect between the two former partners was a nice touch.
What didn't: it was the shortest match on the main card, shorter than the semifinals, and it never got going. It felt like a step to get to the ending rather than a title match in its own right.
Our rating: ★★¾
Sheamus cashes in on Roman Reigns
Reigns celebrated with confetti and pyro. Triple H came to the ring and offered his hand, and Reigns speared him. Then Sheamus ran in with a Brogue Kick and cashed in his Money in the Bank contract. Reigns kicked out of the first pin, but a second Brogue Kick put him down at 0:38. Sheamus and Triple H celebrated together, showing that Sheamus had replaced Rollins as The Authority's champion.
Reigns' first title reign lasted about five minutes.
What worked: the cash-in was a real surprise in the moment, and it gave Reigns an obvious reason to chase the title through the winter.
What didn't: it was the same kind of finish WWE had used before, and Sheamus, who had been made to look foolish earlier in the night, was not a convincing champion. It made the whole tournament feel like a setup.
Our rating: Not rated
Our verdict
Survivor Series 2015 is a weak show with a few good moments. Ambrose vs. Owens is the match to watch, Reigns vs. Del Rio is solid, and The Undertaker's anniversary is a nice piece of history. But the final was rushed, the cash-in made the main event feel like a setup, and too many matches had no story behind them.
If you only have time for a few, watch Ambrose vs. Owens, Reigns vs. Del Rio and The Undertaker's entrance.
Overall: ★★½ (2.5 out of 5)
Star ratings for every match
| Match | Result | Time | Our rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kickoff: Dudleys, Goldust, Neville and O'Neil vs. Miz, Dallas, Stardust and The Ascension | Dudleys, Goldust and O'Neil survived | 18:10 | ★★½ |
| Semifinal: Roman Reigns vs. Alberto Del Rio | Reigns won | 14:05 | ★★★¼ |
| Semifinal: Dean Ambrose vs. Kevin Owens | Ambrose won | 11:20 | ★★★½ |
| New Day, Sheamus and Barrett vs. Usos, Lucha Dragons and Ryback | Ryback, Kalisto and Jey Uso survived | 17:33 | ★★★ |
| Charlotte (c) vs. Paige, Divas Championship | Charlotte retained | 14:18 | ★★½ |
| Tyler Breeze vs. Dolph Ziggler | Breeze won | 6:41 | ★★ |
| The Undertaker and Kane vs. Bray Wyatt and Luke Harper | The Brothers of Destruction won | 10:18 | ★★½ |
| Final: Roman Reigns vs. Dean Ambrose, WWE World Heavyweight Championship | Reigns won the title | 9:02 | ★★¾ |
| Sheamus vs. Roman Reigns (c), Money in the Bank cash-in | Sheamus won the title | 0:38 | Not rated |
What happened next
- Reigns got his rematch at TLC in December and lost, then beat Sheamus for the title on Raw the next night. He lost it in the 2016 Royal Rumble match and won it back from Triple H at WrestleMania 32.
- Sheamus formed The League of Nations with Rusev, King Barrett and Alberto Del Rio.
- Ambrose won the Intercontinental Championship from Kevin Owens at TLC.
- A year later, Survivor Series 2016 in Toronto brought back Raw vs. SmackDown. Read our Survivor Series 2016 retro review.
More retro reviews
Other Survivor Series shows we have revisited, rated out of 5:
- Survivor Series 2016: ★★★½ (3.5 out of 5), Goldberg vs. Lesnar and a 53-minute elimination classic
- Survivor Series 2017: ★★★★ (4 out of 5), Lesnar vs. AJ Styles in Houston
- Survivor Series 2018: ★★★½ (3.5 out of 5), Lesnar vs. Bryan and Rousey vs. Flair
- Survivor Series 2019: ★★★★ (4 out of 5), Raw vs. SmackDown vs. NXT
- Survivor Series 2020: ★★★ (3 out of 5), Reigns vs. McIntyre and The Undertaker's Final Farewell
- Survivor Series 2021: ★★★ (3 out of 5), the last Raw vs. SmackDown Survivor Series
- Survivor Series: WarGames 2022: ★★★★ (4 out of 5), the first WarGames Survivor Series
- Survivor Series: WarGames 2023: ★★★★ (4 out of 5), Randy Orton's return and CM Punk's comeback
- Survivor Series: WarGames 2024: ★★★½ (3.5 out of 5), Reigns and CM Punk on the same side
- Survivor Series: WarGames 2025: ★★★ (3 out of 5), the first stadium Survivor Series
See them all on our Retro Reviews page, Reigns' full record in Roman Reigns at Survivor Series, and this year's card in our Survivor Series: WarGames 2026 guide.



