Skip to content
NEXT PLESurvivor Series: WarGames 2026Sat, Nov 28, 5:00 PM CST
REVIEW

WWE Survivor Series 2016 Retro Review: Goldberg vs. Lesnar, Raw vs. SmackDown and Every Match Rated

Goldberg stands over Brock Lesnar at WWE Survivor Series 2016 in Toronto
Image via WWE

WWE Survivor Series 2016 took place on Sunday, November 20, 2016, at the Air Canada Centre in Toronto. It was the first Survivor Series of the second brand split, and the first built around Raw against SmackDown for brand supremacy, a theme WWE kept for the next five years.

Looking back, it is a show of two halves: a strong, long men's elimination match that still holds up as one of the best in the show's history, and a main event that lasted 86 seconds and changed the next five months of WWE. In between there is a solid undercard with one good title match and two elimination matches that are fun but forgettable.

The build

  • Raw vs. SmackDown: SmackDown Commissioner Shane McMahon and General Manager Daniel Bryan challenged Raw to three traditional elimination matches: five men, five women and five tag teams per side. Raw Commissioner Stephanie McMahon accepted.
  • Goldberg vs. Brock Lesnar: their only previous match was at WrestleMania XX in 2004, after which both left WWE. Goldberg came back as a pre-order bonus for WWE 2K17, which had Lesnar on its cover, and the two traded words for months before Paul Heyman challenged him on Raw in October. Goldberg had not wrestled in WWE for 12 years.
  • Team SmackDown changes: Baron Corbin was taken off the men's team with a storyline injury, so Shane McMahon put himself in. James Ellsworth was made the team's mascot.
  • The title matches: Sami Zayn was due to face Dolph Ziggler for the Intercontinental Championship, but The Miz won the title back five days before the show. The Brian Kendrick's Cruiserweight Championship match against Kalisto had the whole cruiserweight division riding on it: if Kalisto won, the division would move to SmackDown.

Match by match

Kickoff: T.J. Perkins, Rich Swann and Noam Dar vs. Tony Nese, Drew Gulak and Ariya Daivari

A cruiserweight six-man tag to open the pre-show, with the faces against three of the division's heels. It was the kind of fast, move-heavy match the 205 division was built on, and it ended when Swann hit a standing 450 splash on Daivari for the pin.

What worked: it was a good showcase for a division that was still new to the main roster, and Swann's finish got a real reaction.

What didn't: it had nothing riding on it, and by late 2016 the crowd had already started to lose interest in the cruiserweights on Raw. This was a pre-show filler.

Our rating: ★★½

Kickoff: Kane vs. Luke Harper

A simple big-man match that came out of the Wyatt Family's feud with Team SmackDown in the weeks before. Kane won with a chokeslam after just over nine minutes.

What worked: both men knew exactly what this was and kept it physical.

What didn't: it was a TV match on a pre-show, with no stakes and no story beyond the week before.

Our rating: ★★

Team Raw vs. Team SmackDown (women)

Team Raw: Charlotte Flair (captain), Bayley, Sasha Banks, Nia Jax and Alicia Fox. Team SmackDown: Becky Lynch, Alexa Bliss, Carmella, Naomi and Natalya, who came in as a late replacement when captain Nikki Bella was attacked backstage before the match.

The eliminations came quickly. Fox pinned Carmella with a scissors kick and was pinned by Bliss straight after. Naomi was counted out after Jax attacked her on the floor. Natalya rolled up Banks, then took a big boot from Charlotte. Lynch made Jax tap to the Dis-arm-her, the best moment of the match, before Charlotte pinned Bliss. It came down to Lynch against Bayley and Charlotte, and Bayley pinned Lynch with the Bayley-to-Belly to give Raw the win in 17:30.

The story continued after the bell, when Charlotte attacked her own partner Bayley. That set up their rivalry for the Raw Women's Championship, which Bayley won in February.

What worked: Lynch's run near the end, as the SmackDown Women's Champion fighting alone, gave the match some heart, and Charlotte's post-match attack was a smart way to start the next story. Bliss looked good in her short time too.

What didn't: the eliminations came too fast to build drama, and the Nikki Bella attack was never properly explained on the night. Too many good wrestlers had too little time.

Our rating: ★★★

Intercontinental Championship: The Miz (c) vs. Sami Zayn

Zayn had earned a shot at Dolph Ziggler's title, but The Miz won it back on SmackDown's 900th episode five days earlier, so Zayn got Miz instead. It was the best singles match on the undercard. Zayn was full of energy and the Canadian crowd was fully behind the man from Montreal. Miz worked like the cowardly champion he was at the time, with Maryse at ringside.

The finish was clever. Zayn locked Miz in the figure-four, and as Miz was about to tap, Maryse rang the bell. Zayn let go, thinking he had won, and Miz rolled him up to keep the title at 14:05.

What worked: two very good performers, a hot crowd and a finish that made sense for the characters. Miz was on one of the best runs of his career, and this match is a good example of it.

What didn't: it was a Raw vs. SmackDown match that nobody cared about as a brand battle, and Zayn losing to a trick again was a pattern by then. It needed a couple more minutes to feel like a real title match.

Our rating: ★★★½

Team Raw vs. Team SmackDown (tag teams)

Ten teams and twenty wrestlers, with both members of a team eliminated together. Team Raw had The New Day, Cesaro and Sheamus, Enzo and Cass, Gallows and Anderson and The Shining Stars. Team SmackDown had Heath Slater and Rhyno, The Usos, American Alpha, The Hype Bros and Breezango.

Breezango opened by writing tickets to everyone and were eliminated in 42 seconds by The New Day, who were then eliminated by a superkick from The Usos only 24 seconds later. The Raw Tag Team Champions gone in the first two minutes was a real surprise. From there, Gallows and Anderson took out The Hype Bros and American Alpha before Rhyno speared Gallows. Enzo and Cass beat Slater and Rhyno, The Usos beat Enzo and Cass, and it came down to The Usos against Cesaro and Sheamus. Cesaro made Jey tap to the Sharpshooter while Sheamus held off Jimmy, and Raw won in 18:55.

What worked: it moved quickly, nearly every team got a moment, and The Usos and The Bar in the final stretch was the start of a rivalry that gave WWE some of its best tag matches over the next year.

What didn't: twenty wrestlers in under 19 minutes meant almost no one got a proper run, and The New Day being thrown out in the first two minutes made the champions look like an afterthought.

Our rating: ★★★

Cruiserweight Championship: The Brian Kendrick (c) vs. Kalisto

The stipulation was bigger than the match: a Kalisto win would move the whole cruiserweight division to SmackDown. They had a decent, quick match, with Kalisto's speed against Kendrick's veteran cheating. Then Baron Corbin, who had been taken off Team SmackDown, ran in and attacked Kendrick, then Kalisto. Kendrick won by disqualification at 12:25 and the division stayed on Raw.

What worked: Corbin's run-in made sense for his character, and it led to a feud with Kalisto on SmackDown.

What didn't: a disqualification finish in a match with a big stipulation is always frustrating, and the crowd had not been given a reason to care about either man.

Our rating: ★★

Team Raw vs. Team SmackDown (men)

Team Raw: Kevin Owens, Chris Jericho, Braun Strowman, Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins. Team SmackDown: AJ Styles (captain), Dean Ambrose, Bray Wyatt, Randy Orton and Shane McMahon, with James Ellsworth at ringside.

At 52 minutes and 55 seconds, this is one of the longest matches in Survivor Series history, and it never feels it. SmackDown's two former rivals Ambrose and Styles started arguing and fighting each other, and Strowman pinned Ambrose with a running powerslam while Styles watched without helping. Strowman was booked as a monster all match, and it took an RKO onto the announce table and a Leap of Faith from Shane through it to slow him down. Ellsworth then grabbed his legs from under the ring so he was counted out, and Strowman threw him off the stage in revenge.

Owens cost his own team when he attacked Styles with Jericho's clipboard, the List of Jericho, and was disqualified, and Orton pinned a heartbroken Jericho with an RKO. Reigns speared Shane out of the air during a Coast to Coast, a spot that still looks brutal, and the referee stopped it. Ambrose came back and joined Reigns and Rollins in a Shield powerbomb through the announce table on Styles, which let Rollins pin him.

The final minutes were the best part. Orton hit an RKO on Rollins to let Wyatt pin him, leaving Reigns against Wyatt and Orton. Reigns went for a spear on Wyatt, Orton pushed his partner out of the way and took it himself, and Wyatt pinned Reigns with Sister Abigail for the win.

What worked: almost everything. Every man had a moment, the comedy with the List of Jericho and Ellsworth fitted in without spoiling the action, and the finish told a real story. Orton taking a spear for Wyatt was the start of the angle that led to their WrestleMania match, and the crowd was loud all the way through. It is No. 7 in our 10 best Survivor Series matches ever.

What didn't: at almost 53 minutes, a few early stretches drag, and Owens' disqualification was an odd way to remove the Universal Champion from the match. Some fans also wanted Reigns or Styles to be the last man standing.

Our rating: ★★★★¼

Goldberg vs. Brock Lesnar

One of the most famous upsets in WWE history. Lesnar was on a run of dominant wins, and most fans expected him to win easily against a 49-year-old who had not wrestled in 12 years. Lesnar charged Goldberg into the corner, Goldberg shoved him down, and then hit two spears and a Jackhammer. It was over in 1 minute and 26 seconds.

Lesnar never hit a move. The crowd in Toronto went from disbelief to cheering as Goldberg celebrated, and Heyman's face said everything.

What worked: as a moment, it was perfect. Nobody saw it coming, and it made the Goldberg vs. Lesnar rematch one of the biggest matches of WrestleMania 33. It also showed how much a surprise can still mean in wrestling.

What didn't: as a match, there was almost nothing to it, and making Lesnar look this weak in his first loss in a long time was a big call. It worked because WWE had a plan for it, but this is not one to watch for the wrestling.

Our rating: ★★

Our verdict

Survivor Series 2016 is a good show with one great match and one unforgettable moment. The men's elimination match is the reason to watch it, Miz vs. Zayn is a strong undercard match, and the tag and women's elimination matches are fun but too rushed. The Goldberg squash is two minutes of television that changed the road to WrestleMania.

If you only have time for a few, watch the men's elimination match, Miz vs. Zayn and, for the shock of it, Goldberg vs. Lesnar.

Overall: ★★★½ (3.5 out of 5)

Star ratings for every match

WWE Survivor Series 2016: results and our ratings
MatchResultTimeOur rating
Kickoff: Perkins, Swann and Dar vs. Nese, Gulak and DaivariPerkins, Swann and Dar won11:50★★½
Kickoff: Kane vs. Luke HarperKane won9:10★★
Team Raw vs. Team SmackDown (women)Team Raw won (Charlotte Flair and Bayley survived)17:30★★★
The Miz (c) vs. Sami Zayn, Intercontinental ChampionshipMiz retained14:05★★★½
Team Raw vs. Team SmackDown (tag teams)Team Raw won (Cesaro and Sheamus survived)18:55★★★
The Brian Kendrick (c) vs. Kalisto, Cruiserweight ChampionshipKendrick retained by DQ12:25★★
Team Raw vs. Team SmackDown (men)Team SmackDown won (Bray Wyatt and Randy Orton survived)52:55★★★★¼
Goldberg vs. Brock LesnarGoldberg won1:26★★

What happened next

  • Raw won two of the three elimination matches, the women's and the tag teams, and SmackDown won the men's. Both champions kept their titles, Miz for SmackDown and Kendrick for Raw.
  • Goldberg won the Universal Championship from Kevin Owens at Fastlane in March 2017, and Lesnar beat him for it at WrestleMania 33.
  • Wyatt won the WWE Championship at Elimination Chamber in February, and Orton beat him for it at WrestleMania 33.
  • Charlotte's attack on Bayley led to their feud over the Raw Women's Championship, which Bayley won in February 2017.
  • A year later, Survivor Series 2017 in Houston kept the brand supremacy format. Read our Survivor Series 2017 retro review.

More retro reviews

Other Survivor Series shows we have revisited, rated out of 5:

See them all on our Retro Reviews page, and the 40th Survivor Series card in our Survivor Series: WarGames 2026 guide.

Parth
Written byParthParth is the founder and lead editor of WrestleSeek. He got into professional wrestling nearly 20 years ago through TNA and has followed WWE and the wider industry closely for more than 15 years, including over three years in the wrestling community on X (Twitter). Away from wrestling, he is an avid reader, follows cricket and keeps up with the Marvel universe.
All stories by Parth →